Contact us today

  • Phone01638 661600
  • Fax01638 661600
  • When is a Will invalid?

    When is a Will invalid?

    In a recent case, a disgruntled daughter tried every trick in the book to have her late father’s Will declared invalid. She failed at every hurdle. Her arguments were:

    There was a previous Will

    No previous Will could be traced and even if one had been found, her father’s most recent Will would supersede any earlier one.

    Her father lacked capacity

    If a person lacks the necessary mental capacity, they cannot make a Will. The daughter could not show that her father lacked capacity.

    There was undue influence

    If someone is pressured into making a Will, the Will is not valid. In this case, the Judge did find that the father’s relationship with the other two children raised a presumption of undue influence, but on the facts the Judge found that the father made his own decisions.

    A 1975 Act claim

    If family members or other dependents feel that they should have received something or should have received more than they have, they can try to claim using the Inheritance and Family Provisions Act 1975.

    In this case, the daughter did not succeed as other circumstances in the case meant that there was nothing left in the estate to receive!


  • 2023
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014
  • 2013
  • Julie McDonald Family Law Copyright 2024 Managed By Markup Design Ltd
    Julie McDonald Family Law is the trading name of JM Family Law Limited. JM Family Law Limited is a limited company registered in England and Wales [registered number 12606147].
    Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority [number 835268] and is subject to the SRA Code of Conduct.
    Our registered office and address for service of documents is Cleveland House, 39 Old Station Road, Newmarket, Suffolk CB8 8QE.
    JM Family Law Limited is VAT registered and our VAT number is 406 6950 87.